Choosing a Cat Sitter - Who’s Feeding Your Cat—Who’s Holding Your Keys?

Choosing a cat sitter means trusting someone with both your pet's care and access to your home.

A new sitter may have fewer references. That does not automatically make them unsuitable, but it does mean you have less previous experience to draw on. 

Who will actually enter your home? 

The person you meet may not be the only person doing the visits. 

Ask whether they ever send a substitute, bring a companion or share duties with someone else. Agree in advance on who is permitted to enter your home and how any change will be discussed with you. 

Be clear about the visits too. How often will they come? How long will they stay? Will they send you a message or photograph after each visit? 

Put the agreed arrangements in writing so you both have something to refer to. 

Give them what they need 

Leave clear instructions about food, medication, litter and your cat’s habits, along with your vet’s details and an emergency contact. 

For access to the house, provide what is needed for the job. If your alarm system allows a separate temporary code, consider using one. Put personal papers and valuables away and explain which rooms the sitter needs to use. Agree on how the key will be returned when you get home. 

Pay attention to unanswered questions 

A pleasant manner is reassuring, but it does not answer practical questions. 

If someone avoids giving their full name, provides inconsistent details or pressures you to decide before you have checked references, pause and ask for clarification. An unanswered question is a reason to look more closely, not proof that someone has done anything wrong. 

You are looking for someone who will care for your cat and respect your home. Taking time to check the arrangement beforehand can help you leave with greater confidence—and enjoy your trip.